Fair Use: An Oft-Misunderstood Copyright Rule

Editors Note: We would like to again welcome Matt Lowe who has kindly written this guest post about the Fair Use of text and pictures for bloggers writing about other artists creations (very relevant to CraftGossip!). A few weeks ago, he wrote about differences between trademark and copyright.

Matt is an in house counsel in Colorado and is the author of the An Etsy Seller’s Guide to Copyright Protection (for sale). Matt is a Graduate of Pepperdine University School of Law and lives in Salt Lake City, UT,  with his wife and 2 toddler boys (and a baby girl on the way).

If you have any questions for Matt, please leave them in the comments.

Let’s say that you operate a successful blog where you highlight the work of artists, craftspeople, and Etsy sellers.  One day, you stumble across an Etsy shop named Parisian Streets that sells astoundingly artsy photos of the Parisian cityscape at dusk.  You are captivated by these photos.  You carefully study each one.  And then you decide, “I’ve got to write about Parisian Streets on my blog!”

But then, in the footer of the Etsy shop, you see the following:

“© Parisian Streets 2011. Please do not copy, reproduce, or use any content without our written permission. Thank you.”

So, can you write about Parisian Streets on your blog?  Can you show the photos on your blog? Where does this leave you?

Technically speaking, the owner of a copyright (Parisian Streets, in this case) is the only person with the right to show, reproduce, copy, sell or use its work.

However, there is an oft-misunderstood copyright rule known as the “Fair Use Doctrine.”  This doctrine allows you (the blog writer) to write about Parisian Streets so long as you do so only in the capacity of comment, criticism, reporting, information, research, or teaching.

In other words, you are not allowed to (i) confuse consumers as to who owns the photos, (ii) copy or display the photos for your own commercial gain, or (iii) create any adverse effect on Parisian Streets.

The distinction between “Fair Use” and infringement is often cloudy.  There is rarely a bright-line test to ensure that you are within the realm of safety.  So, it’s always best to get permission from Parisian Streets before mentioning or posting any copyrighted material.

In my experience, if Parisian Streets is well aware that you intend to highlight their photos in an informational manner, you will get the consent.  If you don’t get permission, then be very sure that your post falls squarely within the “Fair Use” exception, or don’t publish the post at all.

 It’s a very tenuous dance.  Enjoy it.